The Milk Pail Farm and Orchard
Contact & location
Village of Sag Harbor, NY 11963
Where The Milk Pail Farm and Orchard is located
You'll find The Milk Pail Farm and Orchard just outside Village of Sag Harbor, in the farm country of New York. The setting is small-town, agricultural, and quiet, the sort of drive that feels like the trip is already part of the experience.
From Village of Sag Harbor center, 4 West Water Street, Village of Sag Harbor, NY 11963 is a short drive on county roads. Weekend traffic can back up near the entrance on peak fall Saturdays, arriving before 11 a.m. usually skips the wait.
Nearby you'll find the kind of scenery New York does well in October, farm stands, rural churches, and roads lined with maples turning red. It's a solid half-day out even without leaving Village of Sag Harbor.
Weather at The Milk Pail Farm and Orchard
Live forecast for the orchard's location, check conditions before you head out to pick.
The Milk Pail Farm and Orchard shows up on our directory of New York apple orchards because it's a real, working farm, not an aggregator or affiliate page. Details below reflect what the orchard and its local sources have shared publicly.
Pick-Your-Own Apples at The Milk Pail Farm and Orchard
Pick-your-own is available at The Milk Pail Farm and Orchard during the harvest window. Guests walk the rows, pick straight from the tree, and settle up at the farm stand.
On-Farm Activities
Best Time to Visit
Apple season at The Milk Pail Farm and Orchard tracks the rest of New York. Most fruit ripens between late August and late October. If you can only make one trip, late September through early October gives you the best odds of finding both early and mid-season apples on the trees at the same time.
Weekend mornings between 9 a.m. and noon are the friendliest arrival window. If you can swing a weekday, Tuesday or Wednesday mornings are the quietest, some visitors report having entire rows to themselves.
What to Bring
- • Cash (backup for the farm stand)
- • Closed-toe walking shoes
- • A light jacket or flannel
- • Sunscreen and a hat
- • Water bottles for the walk
- • Reusable bags for the ride home
- • A camera or phone charged for photos
- • Small bills for cider and donuts
Where The Milk Pail Farm and Orchard is located
You'll find The Milk Pail Farm and Orchard just outside Village of Sag Harbor, in the farm country of New York. The setting is small-town, agricultural, and quiet, the sort of drive that feels like the trip is already part of the experience.
From Village of Sag Harbor center, 4 West Water Street, Village of Sag Harbor, NY 11963 is a short drive on county roads. Weekend traffic can back up near the entrance on peak fall Saturdays, arriving before 11 a.m. usually skips the wait.
Nearby you'll find the kind of scenery New York does well in October, farm stands, rural churches, and roads lined with maples turning red. It's a solid half-day out even without leaving Village of Sag Harbor.
Weather at The Milk Pail Farm and Orchard
Live forecast for the orchard's location, check conditions before you head out to pick.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does The Milk Pail Farm and Orchard offer pick-your-own apples?+
Yes. The Milk Pail Farm and Orchard runs pick-your-own during the apple harvest. Guests walk the rows, pick straight from the tree, and pay at the farm stand.
What else is there to do at The Milk Pail Farm and Orchard?+
Beyond picking, The Milk Pail Farm and Orchard offers pick-your-own.
Data source: USDA Local Food Portal · Confidence: High
Visitor reviews
Be the first to review The Milk Pail Farm and Orchard.
More apple orchards in New York
See all →Jamesville, NY
Adams Acres, Organic Apples
Town of LaFayette, NY
Beak and Skiff Apple Farms, Inc.
Fonda, NY
Sand Flats Orchard
Peru, NY
Applejacks Orchard
Penn Yan, NY
Apple Barrel Orchards
New Paltz, NY
Apple Hill Farm
Plan the rest of your apple day
What's ripening these days →
See which varieties are ready to pick right now across New York.
Apple varieties guide →
Compare 50+ apples by taste, texture, and best use before you visit.
Recipes for your haul →
Pies, crisps, cider, butter, and more, tested with fresh-picked apples.
U-Pick day checklist →
What to bring, what to ask, and how to pick apples that store well.
More orchards near you →
Find the closest U-Pick farms sorted by distance from your location.
Read the orchard blog →
Seasonal guides, apple news, and tips from growers across the US.